Tuesday, September 7, 2010
"The Raven" By Edgar Allen Poe
In "The Raven" Edgar Allen Poe writes about melancholy. Melancholy is a feeling that experiences two very different emotions at the same time. This emotion is very confusing for the protaginist. He is not sure whether the raven is good or bad; the raven is both "stately" and "ghastly grim and ancient" (Poe 1-2). Poe's use of rhetoric in this poem, causes the reader to understand conflicting emotions; "Eagerly I wished the morrow; - vainly I had sought to borrow" (Poe 1). He wishes for two different things, just like the raven tells him two different things. It is because these confusing emotions are acceptable and Poe is trying to tell his readers that. He is using Pathos to write this peom; he uses his own emotions through the character and the raven and his own emotions are confused. But it is okay to be confused and that is why the raven keeps telling him "nevermore" (3). There aren't always going to be clear meanings to understand. Poe's poem describes the confusion of life and interpretation and the idea of conflicing emotions.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Molly, I was really interested in your different approach than what most other people (myself included) took. Although most people discussed melancholy and its two different sides, the confusion and satisfaction with confusion is a fresh idea that I agree with. Your point on intent is also very thoughtful, since another reason for Poe's intent could have been to tell readers that it is okay to feel confused-like you said. Just be carefull with saying that Poe uses the poem to exemplify his own emotions without support since it could be argued that he wrote the poem based on someone else's experience-not his own. Good job!
ReplyDeleteyahhh molly! good job and really interesting idea! I agree that it was a different approach and I really liked your points. However, I would be careful that you don't say things like "Poe wishes" because it sounds like you are speaking on behalf of Poe and not expressing your own opinions(even though I know that its your own points). Besides that it was really good and I really liked it. SOLID WORK =D
ReplyDeleteHey molly!
ReplyDeleteOk a few sentences in you say "Poe's use of rhetoric in this poem, causes the reader to understand conflicting emotions..." however before this you never make specific connections to rhetoric! You give the definition of melancholy and explain the use pof this tone, however clarifying where the rhetoric is used specifially would definitely strengthen this argument!
Otherwise great job!
See you tomorrow,
Liz
Also you say that poe is using pathos, if you provide the reader with textual evidence to support this claim it would definitely enhance this response.
whoops don't know what my "otherwise" and signiture got mixed up that should be after the "also you say.." sorry!
ReplyDelete